{ "about": { "method": "influence-leave-one-out", "methodVersion": "1.0.0", "memo": "docs/board/memos/2026-10-13-cso-a4-diagnostics.md", "tolerances": { "delta": "0.00086 absolute in log10 units", "outcome (shown, or the rule that withheld)": "exact", "largest (well named)": "exact" }, "origin": "The worked MTT plate (pipeline/assay-analyser/fixtures/mtt-example.json) and constructed curves (seeded noise, numpy default_rng)", "recordedOn": "2026-10-13", "script": "pipeline/assay-analyser/oracles/influence_loo.py", "scriptSha256": "13a180928272c4cb88e0f9f238fe61d501a1d6aae78d4a213f53f9db4c5d7568", "helper": { "script": "pipeline/assay-analyser/oracles/stage_a_oracle.py", "sha256": "492d85ca2fa6750db80b1c64214fd4a0b13cd4c588267244f6262c504c73e3e8" }, "environment": { "image": "ghcr.io/biotechmat/drybench/oracle-env:11b8a5e4456df7eb@sha256:7e69891ca1d9f24838660e0a9887bdb654ce7771d2f2ac7e7275e9b1eb3b6a09", "r": "R version 4.4.3 (2025-02-28)", "packages": { "drc": "4.0-0", "jsonlite": "2.0.0" }, "python": "3.11.15", "numpy": "2.0.2", "scipy": "1.13.1", "recordedOn": "2026-10-13", "cpu": "AMD EPYC 9V45 96-Core Processor", "cpuClass": "x86-64-v3", "simd": [ "SSSE3", "SSE41", "POPCNT", "SSE42", "AVX", "F16C", "FMA3", "AVX2" ], "openblasCore": "Haswell", "threads": 1 }, "crossCheck": { "tool": "R drc LL.4", "ran": true, "r": "R version 4.4.3 (2025-02-28)", "drc": "4.0.0", "worstAbsoluteDelta": 1.2397010120644703e-06, "tolerance": 0.00086, "agrees": true, "drcFailed": [] } }, "cases": [ { "name": "Compound A", "about": "The worked MTT plate, Compound A: every kept well left out in turn", "curve": { "id": "Compound A", "wells": [ "A2", "A3", "A4", "A5", "A6", "A7", "A8", "A9", "A10", "A11", "B2", "B3", "B4", "B5", "B6", "B7", "B8", "B9", "B10", "B11", "C2", "C3", "C4", "C5", "C6", "C7", "C8", "C9", "C10", "C11" ], "x": [ -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962 ], "y": [ 4.14595452141724, 5.33051295610788, 12.860920148069804, 35.5367530407192, 74.6271813855103, 81.73453199365414, 105.93336858804865, 86.47276573241672, 107.7102062400846, 100.2644103648863, 3.2998413537810687, 6.345848757271286, 12.522474881015334, 33.0830248545743, 68.87361184558435, 83.76520359598096, 99.84135378106822, 97.2184029613961, 95.10312004230565, 96.96456901110523, 3.2998413537810687, 8.122686409307244, 13.453199365415124, 32.575356953992596, 65.40454785827605, 86.81121099947119, 88.9264939185616, 102.2104706504495, 97.2184029613961, 96.96456901110523 ], "fixed": {}, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": true, "estimates": { "top": 98.23627953208944, "bottom": 3.0369018010253126, "logIC50": -5.665647204192236, "hill": -1.2823903912343009 }, "rss": 565.5376752025097 }, "rows": [ { "index": 0, "well": "A2", "x": -4.0, "y": 4.14595452141724, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.664716934034631, "delta": 0.0009302701576050509 }, { "index": 1, "well": "A3", "x": -4.477121254719663, "y": 5.33051295610788, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.666320108284761, "delta": -0.0006729040925250729 }, { "index": 2, "well": "A4", "x": -4.954242509439325, "y": 12.860920148069804, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.6654171086488425, "delta": 0.00023009554339381566 }, { "index": 3, "well": "A5", "x": -5.431363764158987, "y": 35.5367530407192, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.668275696271462, "delta": -0.002628492079225886 }, { "index": 4, "well": "A6", "x": -5.9084850188786495, "y": 74.6271813855103, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.690210018912072, "delta": -0.024562814719836013 }, { "index": 5, "well": "A7", "x": -6.385606273598312, "y": 81.73453199365414, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.663485462472523, "delta": 0.0021617417197132838 }, { "index": 6, "well": "A8", "x": -6.862727528317975, "y": 105.93336858804865, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.6594358574448735, "delta": 0.006211346747362789 }, { "index": 7, "well": "A9", "x": -7.339848783037637, "y": 86.47276573241672, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.674968080567584, "delta": -0.009320876375348064 }, { "index": 8, "well": "A10", "x": -7.8169700377573, "y": 107.7102062400846, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.6572918401860255, "delta": 0.008355364006210841 }, { "index": 9, "well": "A11", "x": -8.294091292476962, "y": 100.2644103648863, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.663803732628507, "delta": 0.0018434715637294374 }, { "index": 10, "well": "B2", "x": -4.0, "y": 3.2998413537810687, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.666593324395974, "delta": -0.0009461202037375216 }, { "index": 11, "well": "B3", "x": -4.477121254719663, "y": 6.345848757271286, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.664870791229389, "delta": 0.0007764129628471395 }, { "index": 12, "well": "B4", "x": -4.954242509439325, "y": 12.522474881015334, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.665272467774733, "delta": 0.0003747364175037404 }, { "index": 13, "well": "B5", "x": -5.431363764158987, "y": 33.0830248545743, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.659488280189119, "delta": 0.006158924003117683 }, { "index": 14, "well": "B6", "x": -5.9084850188786495, "y": 68.87361184558435, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.671576555855523, "delta": -0.005929351663287008 }, { "index": 15, "well": "B7", "x": -6.385606273598312, "y": 83.76520359598096, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.66408960056551, "delta": 0.0015576036267264115 }, { "index": 16, "well": "B8", "x": -6.862727528317975, "y": 99.84135378106822, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.663078271118532, "delta": 0.002568933073704649 }, { "index": 17, "well": "B9", "x": -7.339848783037637, "y": 97.2184029613961, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.66593342181409, "delta": -0.0002862176218538792 }, { "index": 18, "well": "B10", "x": -7.8169700377573, "y": 95.10312004230565, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.668291672424086, "delta": -0.002644468231849828 }, { "index": 19, "well": "B11", "x": -8.294091292476962, "y": 96.96456901110523, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.666754005502833, "delta": -0.0011068013105965946 }, { "index": 20, "well": "C2", "x": -4.0, "y": 3.2998413537810687, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.666593320941427, "delta": -0.0009461167491906508 }, { "index": 21, "well": "C3", "x": -4.477121254719663, "y": 8.122686409307244, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.662337882568301, "delta": 0.0033093216239352685 }, { "index": 22, "well": "C4", "x": -4.954242509439325, "y": 13.453199365415124, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.665661913508651, "delta": -1.4709316414673879e-05 }, { "index": 23, "well": "C5", "x": -5.431363764158987, "y": 32.575356953992596, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.6576530263973925, "delta": 0.007994177794843793 }, { "index": 24, "well": "C6", "x": -5.9084850188786495, "y": 65.40454785827605, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.660602679259009, "delta": 0.005044524933227379 }, { "index": 25, "well": "C7", "x": -6.385606273598312, "y": 86.81121099947119, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.665147341430095, "delta": 0.0004998627621413121 }, { "index": 26, "well": "C8", "x": -6.862727528317975, "y": 88.9264939185616, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.669588141487807, "delta": -0.00394093729557099 }, { "index": 27, "well": "C9", "x": -7.339848783037637, "y": 102.2104706504495, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.661799294081684, "delta": 0.0038479101105526325 }, { "index": 28, "well": "C10", "x": -7.8169700377573, "y": 97.2184029613961, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.66640308707815, "delta": -0.0007558828859135502 }, { "index": 29, "well": "C11", "x": -8.294091292476962, "y": 96.96456901110523, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.6667540088283, "delta": -0.0011068046360636075 } ], "largest": { "index": 4, "well": "A6" } } }, { "name": "Compound B", "about": "The worked MTT plate, Compound B: every kept well left out in turn", "curve": { "id": "Compound B", "wells": [ "D2", "D3", "D4", "D5", "D6", "D7", "D8", "D9", "D10", "D11", "E2", "E3", "E4", "E5", "E6", "E7", "E8", "E9", "E10", "E11", "F2", "F3", "F4", "F5", "F6", "F7", "F8", "F9", "F10", "F11" ], "x": [ -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962 ], "y": [ 16.414595452141725, 18.02221047065045, 15.314648334214699, 19.71443680592279, 22.083553675304074, 39.09042834479112, 62.527763088313066, 73.44262295081968, 98.3183500793231, 89.09571655208885, 15.314648334214699, 16.076150185087254, 18.191433104177687, 21.660497091485986, 28.514013749338975, 42.89793759915388, 62.189317821258605, 80.88841882601797, 89.8572184029614, 94.17239555790587, 12.437863564251717, 17.091485986250664, 18.02221047065045, 17.176097303014277, 26.906398730830247, 43.15177154944474, 61.427815970386035, 79.78847170809094, 94.51084082496034, 93.49550502379694 ], "fixed": {}, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": true, "estimates": { "top": 96.78878389902883, "bottom": 15.538387446334902, "logIC50": -6.73539803183427, "hill": -0.9791144934350114 }, "rss": 227.5341772138992 }, "rows": [ { "index": 0, "well": "D2", "x": -4.0, "y": 16.414595452141725, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.734546243612497, "delta": 0.0008517882217731199 }, { "index": 1, "well": "D3", "x": -4.477121254719663, "y": 18.02221047065045, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.732913600782329, "delta": 0.002484431051941627 }, { "index": 2, "well": "D4", "x": -4.954242509439325, "y": 15.314648334214699, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.7374918184188965, "delta": -0.0020937865846262227 }, { "index": 3, "well": "D5", "x": -5.431363764158987, "y": 19.71443680592279, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.7352965346106055, "delta": 0.00010149722366481484 }, { "index": 4, "well": "D6", "x": -5.9084850188786495, "y": 22.083553675304074, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.73465424048092, "delta": 0.0007437913533498985 }, { "index": 5, "well": "D7", "x": -6.385606273598312, "y": 39.09042834479112, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.7291483480698355, "delta": 0.006249683764434799 }, { "index": 6, "well": "D8", "x": -6.862727528317975, "y": 62.527763088313066, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.738603678189482, "delta": -0.0032056463552114778 }, { "index": 7, "well": "D9", "x": -7.339848783037637, "y": 73.44262295081968, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.7192748213669535, "delta": 0.016123210467316795 }, { "index": 8, "well": "D10", "x": -7.8169700377573, "y": 98.3183500793231, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.721074193038171, "delta": 0.01432383879609933 }, { "index": 9, "well": "D11", "x": -8.294091292476962, "y": 89.09571655208885, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.764260292717221, "delta": -0.028862260882950963 }, { "index": 10, "well": "E2", "x": -4.0, "y": 15.314648334214699, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.735872306762104, "delta": -0.00047427492783391756 }, { "index": 11, "well": "E3", "x": -4.477121254719663, "y": 16.076150185087254, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.7353468295703, "delta": 5.120226397004046e-05 }, { "index": 12, "well": "E4", "x": -4.954242509439325, "y": 18.191433104177687, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.733865203825687, "delta": 0.0015328280085835644 }, { "index": 13, "well": "E5", "x": -5.431363764158987, "y": 21.660497091485986, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.73324738059608, "delta": 0.0021506512381899157 }, { "index": 14, "well": "E6", "x": -5.9084850188786495, "y": 28.514013749338975, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.735629167516244, "delta": -0.00023113568197352663 }, { "index": 15, "well": "E7", "x": -6.385606273598312, "y": 42.89793759915388, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.741947272015945, "delta": -0.006549240181674243 }, { "index": 16, "well": "E8", "x": -6.862727528317975, "y": 62.189317821258605, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.736709830299375, "delta": -0.0013117984651049852 }, { "index": 17, "well": "E9", "x": -7.339848783037637, "y": 80.88841882601797, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.737167659430383, "delta": -0.001769627596112322 }, { "index": 18, "well": "E10", "x": -7.8169700377573, "y": 89.8572184029614, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.736108457412957, "delta": -0.0007104255786867242 }, { "index": 19, "well": "E11", "x": -8.294091292476962, "y": 94.17239555790587, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.736767849824391, "delta": -0.001369817990120481 }, { "index": 20, "well": "F2", "x": -4.0, "y": 12.437863564251717, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.7393202134945644, "delta": -0.003922181660294122 }, { "index": 21, "well": "F3", "x": -4.477121254719663, "y": 17.091485986250664, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.734079691638788, "delta": 0.0013183401954819374 }, { "index": 22, "well": "F4", "x": -4.954242509439325, "y": 18.02221047065045, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.734079109694761, "delta": 0.0013189221395091266 }, { "index": 23, "well": "F5", "x": -5.431363764158987, "y": 17.176097303014277, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.737985961480606, "delta": -0.002587929646336029 }, { "index": 24, "well": "F6", "x": -5.9084850188786495, "y": 26.906398730830247, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.735456491330754, "delta": -5.845949648364268e-05 }, { "index": 25, "well": "F7", "x": -6.385606273598312, "y": 43.15177154944474, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.742778404237305, "delta": -0.007380372403035018 }, { "index": 26, "well": "F8", "x": -6.862727528317975, "y": 61.427815970386035, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.732449064437758, "delta": 0.002948967396512181 }, { "index": 27, "well": "F9", "x": -7.339848783037637, "y": 79.78847170809094, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.7342316914744815, "delta": 0.0011663403597887978 }, { "index": 28, "well": "F10", "x": -7.8169700377573, "y": 94.51084082496034, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.727918277535646, "delta": 0.007479754298624464 }, { "index": 29, "well": "F11", "x": -8.294091292476962, "y": 93.49550502379694, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.740272409988101, "delta": -0.0048743781538309605 } ], "largest": { "index": 9, "well": "D11" } } }, { "name": "Compound C", "about": "The worked MTT plate, Compound C: every kept well left out in turn", "curve": { "id": "Compound C", "wells": [ "G2", "G3", "G4", "G5", "G6", "G7", "G8", "G9", "G10", "G11", "H2", "H3", "H4", "H5", "H6", "H7", "H8", "H9", "H10", "H11" ], "x": [ -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962 ], "y": [ 37.65203595980962, 69.04283447911159, 78.01163405605499, 90.70333157059756, 96.11845584346906, 90.70333157059756, 100.51824431517716, 105.6795346377578, 99.33368588048651, 103.05658381808567, 43.40560549973558, 70.90428344791117, 88.08038075092543, 92.3955579058699, 99.33368588048651, 105.76414595452141, 92.9032258064516, 100.60285563194077, 109.48704389212058, 105.51031200423056 ], "fixed": {}, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": false, "withheldBy": "no-finite-minimum" }, "rows": [] } }, { "name": "outlier-on-slope", "about": "One gross outlier (+45 percent) at the concentration nearest the C50: the largest shift", "curve": { "id": "outlier", "wells": [ "W1", "W2", "W3", "W4", "W5", "W6", "W7", "W8", "W9", "W10", "W11", "W12", "W13", "W14", "W15", "W16", "W17", "W18", "W19", "W20", "W21", "W22", "W23", "W24", "W25", "W26", "W27", "W28", "W29", "W30" ], "x": [ -4.0, -4.0, -4.0, -4.5, -4.5, -4.5, -5.0, -5.0, -5.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.5, -6.0, -6.0, -6.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.5, -7.0, -7.0, -7.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.5, -8.0, -8.0, -8.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.5 ], "y": [ 1.4728487859269626, 4.928560486345592, -4.9624651500183266, 6.620006750180217, 1.418214587714548, -0.8397695289424991, 3.526224155105674, 2.6866447605289876, 5.264158235054408, 22.577653429966645, 21.828192086239085, 21.990858964078722, 89.91557482469295, 45.28711364692579, 54.66140952286896, 82.83065520505981, 86.47364111310775, 83.55344661338567, 90.99173168455957, 97.92072305416005, 95.95008848253423, 99.08430855885379, 95.98021380810138, 98.4481744412387, 99.16247533274348, 102.28107677292924, 99.9769622700809, 104.65433764311881, 97.57664264044547, 101.31340757833121 ], "fixed": {}, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": true, "estimates": { "top": 99.06093963716323, "bottom": -0.38473008932064456, "logIC50": -5.8601583548450265, "hill": -1.3819360294440417 }, "rss": 1373.7536822405493 }, "rows": [ { "index": 0, "well": "W1", "x": -4.0, "y": 1.4728487859269626, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.85783961144127, "delta": 0.0023187434037561516 }, { "index": 1, "well": "W2", "x": -4.0, "y": 4.928560486345592, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.852652676025926, "delta": 0.007505678819100581 }, { "index": 2, "well": "W3", "x": -4.0, "y": -4.9624651500183266, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.866972909769181, "delta": -0.0068145549241549475 }, { "index": 3, "well": "W4", "x": -4.5, "y": 6.620006750180217, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.853267120672487, "delta": 0.006891234172539562 }, { "index": 4, "well": "W5", "x": -4.5, "y": 1.418214587714548, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.859548460303793, "delta": 0.0006098945412338352 }, { "index": 5, "well": "W6", "x": -4.5, "y": -0.8397695289424991, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.862254075003291, "delta": -0.0020957201582643137 }, { "index": 6, "well": "W7", "x": -5.0, "y": 3.526224155105674, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.86091304834413, "delta": -0.0007546934991031762 }, { "index": 7, "well": "W8", "x": -5.0, "y": 2.6866447605289876, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.861200274882046, "delta": -0.0010419200370197501 }, { "index": 8, "well": "W9", "x": -5.0, "y": 5.264158235054408, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.860301929803885, "delta": -0.00014357495885874982 }, { "index": 9, "well": "W10", "x": -5.5, "y": 22.577653429966645, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.857757270179654, "delta": 0.002401084665372366 }, { "index": 10, "well": "W11", "x": -5.5, "y": 21.828192086239085, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.855974433610003, "delta": 0.0041839212350236465 }, { "index": 11, "well": "W12", "x": -5.5, "y": 21.990858964078722, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.856363361806495, "delta": 0.00379499303853148 }, { "index": 12, "well": "W13", "x": -6.0, "y": 89.91557482469295, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.972203636153942, "delta": -0.11204528130891589 }, { "index": 13, "well": "W14", "x": -6.0, "y": 45.28711364692579, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.802342195142771, "delta": 0.05781615970225573 }, { "index": 14, "well": "W15", "x": -6.0, "y": 54.66140952286896, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.838984307432046, "delta": 0.021174047412980457 }, { "index": 15, "well": "W16", "x": -6.5, "y": 82.83065520505981, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.856096162629618, "delta": 0.004062192215408267 }, { "index": 16, "well": "W17", "x": -6.5, "y": 86.47364111310775, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.859131939922526, "delta": 0.0010264149225003294 }, { "index": 17, "well": "W18", "x": -6.5, "y": 83.55344661338567, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.856656527241782, "delta": 0.0035018276032445783 }, { "index": 18, "well": "W19", "x": -7.0, "y": 90.99173168455957, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.862742539966852, "delta": -0.002584185121825122 }, { "index": 19, "well": "W20", "x": -7.0, "y": 97.92072305416005, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.859485585610031, "delta": 0.000672769234995485 }, { "index": 20, "well": "W21", "x": -7.0, "y": 95.95008848253423, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.86040908922874, "delta": -0.00025073438371325807 }, { "index": 21, "well": "W22", "x": -7.5, "y": 99.08430855885379, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.859695619061727, "delta": 0.0004627357832998058 }, { "index": 22, "well": "W23", "x": -7.5, "y": 95.98021380810138, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.862270279554428, "delta": -0.0021119247094016913 }, { "index": 23, "well": "W24", "x": -7.5, "y": 98.4481744412387, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.860221993081323, "delta": -6.36382362966259e-05 }, { "index": 24, "well": "W25", "x": -8.0, "y": 99.16247533274348, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.85996477768716, "delta": 0.00019357715786672003 }, { "index": 25, "well": "W26", "x": -8.0, "y": 102.28107677292924, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.857133473885543, "delta": 0.003024880959483056 }, { "index": 26, "well": "W27", "x": -8.0, "y": 99.9769622700809, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.859220402793344, "delta": 0.0009379520516823447 }, { "index": 27, "well": "W28", "x": -8.5, "y": 104.65433764311881, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.854995844973503, "delta": 0.005162509871523113 }, { "index": 28, "well": "W29", "x": -8.5, "y": 97.57664264044547, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.8615363207679865, "delta": -0.0013779659229600227 }, { "index": 29, "well": "W30", "x": -8.5, "y": 101.31340757833121, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.858042714573411, "delta": 0.002115640271615149 } ], "largest": { "index": 12, "well": "W13" } } }, { "name": "single-well-bracket", "about": "Two concentrations above the midpoint, each a single well, Bottom fixed at 0 (so rule (iv) does not apply to it): leaving either out fires rule (iii)", "curve": { "id": "bracket", "wells": [ "W1", "W2", "W3", "W4", "W5", "W6", "W7", "W8", "W9", "W10", "W11", "W12", "W13", "W14", "W15", "W16", "W17", "W18", "W19", "W20" ], "x": [ -4.0, -5.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.5, -6.0, -6.0, -6.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.5, -7.0, -7.0, -7.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.5, -8.0, -8.0, -8.0 ], "y": [ -0.6892817909135038, 32.9136380244817, 65.70607002479105, 67.74482094182831, 73.9547173891409, 85.31474123732043, 92.9505913049675, 93.90609865931467, 96.25321388248283, 95.21678749958856, 98.73593962168837, 102.95659544001813, 105.77951627960879, 101.98835692270185, 104.60804938563581, 98.47564668738445, 97.203870437237, 94.797047701321, 96.49525970283118, 98.86606631352102 ], "fixed": { "bottom": 0.0 }, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": true, "estimates": { "bottom": 0.0, "top": 99.85448582178566, "logIC50": -5.23797586178754, "hill": -1.3371947903186108 }, "rss": 229.17203939214474 }, "rows": [ { "index": 0, "well": "W1", "x": -4.0, "y": -0.6892817909135038, "shown": false, "withheldBy": "iii" }, { "index": 1, "well": "W2", "x": -5.0, "y": 32.9136380244817, "shown": false, "withheldBy": "iii" }, { "index": 2, "well": "W3", "x": -5.5, "y": 65.70607002479105, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.224585931999949, "delta": 0.013389929787591015 }, { "index": 3, "well": "W4", "x": -5.5, "y": 67.74482094182831, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.232715961342107, "delta": 0.005259900445432564 }, { "index": 4, "well": "W5", "x": -5.5, "y": 73.9547173891409, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.258469696651594, "delta": -0.020493834864054428 }, { "index": 5, "well": "W6", "x": -6.0, "y": 85.31474123732043, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.239880296041017, "delta": -0.001904434253477305 }, { "index": 6, "well": "W7", "x": -6.0, "y": 92.9505913049675, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.237529825464778, "delta": 0.0004460363227618558 }, { "index": 7, "well": "W8", "x": -6.0, "y": 93.90609865931467, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.237329158443914, "delta": 0.0006467033436257097 }, { "index": 8, "well": "W9", "x": -6.5, "y": 96.25321388248283, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.239242597769872, "delta": -0.0012667359823321789 }, { "index": 9, "well": "W10", "x": -6.5, "y": 95.21678749958856, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.2400649117050095, "delta": -0.002089049917469943 }, { "index": 10, "well": "W11", "x": -6.5, "y": 98.73593962168837, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.237265727237359, "delta": 0.0007101345501805412 }, { "index": 11, "well": "W12", "x": -7.0, "y": 102.95659544001813, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.2354057313942866, "delta": 0.002570130393253045 }, { "index": 12, "well": "W13", "x": -7.0, "y": 105.77951627960879, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.233379600693216, "delta": 0.004596261094323317 }, { "index": 13, "well": "W14", "x": -7.0, "y": 101.98835692270185, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.236105447585079, "delta": 0.0018704142024610348 }, { "index": 14, "well": "W15", "x": -7.5, "y": 104.60804938563581, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.2347432255590745, "delta": 0.0032326362284651466 }, { "index": 15, "well": "W16", "x": -7.5, "y": 98.47564668738445, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.238844044851763, "delta": -0.0008681830642229826 }, { "index": 16, "well": "W17", "x": -7.5, "y": 97.203870437237, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.2397087121047266, "delta": -0.0017328503171869514 }, { "index": 17, "well": "W18", "x": -8.0, "y": 94.797047701321, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.241294444227381, "delta": -0.0033185824398414 }, { "index": 18, "well": "W19", "x": -8.0, "y": 96.49525970283118, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.240167555561987, "delta": -0.0021916937744475007 }, { "index": 19, "well": "W20", "x": -8.0, "y": 98.86606631352102, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.238608284922247, "delta": -0.0006324231347072384 } ], "largest": { "index": 4, "well": "W5" } } }, { "name": "four-concentrations", "about": "Four concentrations, one a single well: leaving it out fires rule (i)", "curve": { "id": "four", "wells": [ "W1", "W2", "W3", "W4", "W5", "W6", "W7", "W8", "W9", "W10" ], "x": [ -5.0, -5.0, -5.0, -5.8, -5.8, -5.8, -6.2, -7.0, -7.0, -7.0 ], "y": [ 1.6697807667662063, 0.6628008277584116, -0.16397096349958856, 6.723880576156284, 14.975171363447533, 7.301849506968335, 89.04907479074691, 101.80789771891925, 102.48017094563525, 102.47309603104617 ], "fixed": {}, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": true, "estimates": { "top": 102.256890733437, "bottom": 0.7208223943539629, "logIC50": -6.020612927119287, "hill": -4.600491085372119 }, "rss": 44.417470598470594 }, "rows": [ { "index": 0, "well": "W1", "x": -5.0, "y": 1.6697807667662063, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.018123807299233, "delta": 0.0024891198200540643 }, { "index": 1, "well": "W2", "x": -5.0, "y": 0.6628008277584116, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.020772915440188, "delta": -0.0001599883209006947 }, { "index": 2, "well": "W3", "x": -5.0, "y": -0.16397096349958856, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.023001663077412, "delta": -0.0023887359581253875 }, { "index": 3, "well": "W4", "x": -5.8, "y": 6.723880576156284, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.013191837519817, "delta": 0.0074210895994699655 }, { "index": 4, "well": "W5", "x": -5.8, "y": 14.975171363447533, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.035385270622589, "delta": -0.014772343503302032 }, { "index": 5, "well": "W6", "x": -5.8, "y": 7.301849506968335, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.014618047300391, "delta": 0.005994879818896237 }, { "index": 6, "well": "W7", "x": -6.2, "y": 89.04907479074691, "shown": false, "withheldBy": "i" }, { "index": 7, "well": "W8", "x": -7.0, "y": 101.80789771891925, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.021589785314025, "delta": -0.0009768581947380284 }, { "index": 8, "well": "W9", "x": -7.0, "y": 102.48017094563525, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.020113554704773, "delta": 0.0004993724145139211 }, { "index": 9, "well": "W10", "x": -7.0, "y": 102.47309603104617, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.020129189478437, "delta": 0.00048373764084974624 } ], "largest": { "index": 4, "well": "W5" } } }, { "name": "bottom-fixed", "about": "Bottom fixed at 0: the refits keep it", "curve": { "id": "fixed", "wells": [ "W1", "W2", "W3", "W4", "W5", "W6", "W7", "W8", "W9", "W10", "W11", "W12", "W13", "W14", "W15", "W16", "W17", "W18", "W19", "W20" ], "x": [ -4.0, -4.0, -4.5, -4.5, -5.0, -5.0, -5.5, -5.5, -6.0, -6.0, -6.5, -6.5, -7.0, -7.0, -7.5, -7.5, -8.0, -8.0, -8.5, -8.5 ], "y": [ 4.448770531906899, 1.425800316018245, -1.9288042565912282, 0.9989087513225483, 4.916700523266827, 5.25206533990964, 21.866569372958143, 16.238931472185346, 52.89996598841778, 46.61611793523417, 79.35862352805516, 82.5849658360338, 96.05593640316904, 91.99185682347395, 103.74643212422352, 99.53636246470184, 96.74014533688013, 99.73107478216001, 97.40694274918347, 101.20264402114456 ], "fixed": { "bottom": 0.0 }, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": true, "estimates": { "bottom": 0.0, "top": 100.00182664057454, "logIC50": -6.002502124854038, "hill": -1.265456148845538 }, "rss": 121.61915102722953 }, "rows": [ { "index": 0, "well": "W1", "x": -4.0, "y": 4.448770531906899, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.002450543637728, "delta": 5.158121630977064e-05 }, { "index": 1, "well": "W2", "x": -4.0, "y": 1.425800316018245, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.002487919097847, "delta": 1.4205756190932561e-05 }, { "index": 2, "well": "W3", "x": -4.5, "y": -1.9288042565912282, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.00244704697338, "delta": 5.507788065806096e-05 }, { "index": 3, "well": "W4", "x": -4.5, "y": 0.9989087513225483, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.002498112058061, "delta": 4.012795977281769e-06 }, { "index": 4, "well": "W5", "x": -5.0, "y": 4.916700523266827, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.002429799976115, "delta": 7.232487792308007e-05 }, { "index": 5, "well": "W6", "x": -5.0, "y": 5.25206533990964, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.002553629698242, "delta": -5.150484420379797e-05 }, { "index": 6, "well": "W7", "x": -5.5, "y": 21.866569372958143, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.010202178207688, "delta": -0.007700053353650205 }, { "index": 7, "well": "W8", "x": -5.5, "y": 16.238931472185346, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.995665611521115, "delta": 0.006836513332922678 }, { "index": 8, "well": "W9", "x": -6.0, "y": 52.89996598841778, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.020291732180864, "delta": -0.017789607326825774 }, { "index": 9, "well": "W10", "x": -6.0, "y": 46.61611793523417, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.983650451438231, "delta": 0.01885167341580729 }, { "index": 10, "well": "W11", "x": -6.5, "y": 79.35862352805516, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.996822202555157, "delta": 0.005679922298880591 }, { "index": 11, "well": "W12", "x": -6.5, "y": 82.5849658360338, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.008291612322744, "delta": -0.005789487468706334 }, { "index": 12, "well": "W13", "x": -7.0, "y": 96.05593640316904, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.002405459187286, "delta": 9.666566675203825e-05 }, { "index": 13, "well": "W14", "x": -7.0, "y": 91.99185682347395, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.0028095606447325, "delta": -0.0003074357906944769 }, { "index": 14, "well": "W15", "x": -7.5, "y": 103.74643212422352, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.995459615341737, "delta": 0.0070425095123010095 }, { "index": 15, "well": "W16", "x": -7.5, "y": 99.53636246470184, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.001389366600338, "delta": 0.0011127582536998304 }, { "index": 16, "well": "W17", "x": -8.0, "y": 96.74014533688013, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.008082761857177, "delta": -0.005580637003139266 }, { "index": 17, "well": "W18", "x": -8.0, "y": 99.73107478216001, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.0024555068113274, "delta": 4.6618042710555585e-05 }, { "index": 18, "well": "W19", "x": -8.5, "y": 97.40694274918347, "shown": true, "logIC50": -6.007632129631841, "delta": -0.005130004777803343 }, { "index": 19, "well": "W20", "x": -8.5, "y": 101.20264402114456, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.999977727739974, "delta": 0.0025243971140636035 } ], "largest": { "index": 9, "well": "W10" } } }, { "name": "tied-shifts", "about": "The two wells at the concentration nearest the C50 made identical outliers (+20): equal and largest |delta|; the first in plate order is named", "curve": { "id": "ties", "wells": [ "W1", "W2", "W3", "W4", "W5", "W6", "W7", "W8", "W9", "W10", "W11", "W12", "W13", "W14", "W15", "W16", "W17", "W18", "W19", "W20" ], "x": [ -4.0, -4.0, -4.5, -4.5, -5.0, -5.0, -5.5, -5.5, -6.0, -6.0, -6.5, -6.5, -7.0, -7.0, -7.5, -7.5, -8.0, -8.0, -8.5, -8.5 ], "y": [ 1.4586476143671128, 0.38163245711766675, -0.034627837205012835, -5.26953317797126, 5.9912404427859745, 8.717200761243532, 23.206005028018023, 18.46740668653231, 76.68809147540755, 76.68809147540755, 79.23932066048626, 79.4584557107941, 96.94180069960704, 93.30060932567785, 99.11413191942533, 102.09941442430147, 103.172632971623, 98.0140698704918, 98.53323676732087, 98.2529544302074 ], "fixed": {}, "blocks": [ "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1", "1" ] }, "expected": { "full": { "shown": true, "estimates": { "top": 96.7815828160569, "bottom": -0.5953312954743823, "logIC50": -5.755579706221746, "hill": -1.7372023970373782 }, "rss": 608.9117911864538 }, "rows": [ { "index": 0, "well": "W1", "x": -4.0, "y": 1.4586476143671128, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.752275589440081, "delta": 0.0033041167816652006 }, { "index": 1, "well": "W2", "x": -4.0, "y": 0.38163245711766675, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.754110285613019, "delta": 0.0014694206087266792 }, { "index": 2, "well": "W3", "x": -4.5, "y": -0.034627837205012835, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.755691562219376, "delta": -0.0001118559976296396 }, { "index": 3, "well": "W4", "x": -4.5, "y": -5.26953317797126, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.76311657137176, "delta": -0.007536865150013838 }, { "index": 4, "well": "W5", "x": -5.0, "y": 5.9912404427859745, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.754035935843551, "delta": 0.0015437703781948642 }, { "index": 5, "well": "W6", "x": -5.0, "y": 8.717200761243532, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.751932177003849, "delta": 0.0036475292178970165 }, { "index": 6, "well": "W7", "x": -5.5, "y": 23.206005028018023, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.744913404265754, "delta": 0.010666301955992274 }, { "index": 7, "well": "W8", "x": -5.5, "y": 18.46740668653231, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.719426604821851, "delta": 0.03615310139989525 }, { "index": 8, "well": "W9", "x": -6.0, "y": 76.68809147540755, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.814481776537502, "delta": -0.05890207031575567 }, { "index": 9, "well": "W10", "x": -6.0, "y": 76.68809147540755, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.814481776537502, "delta": -0.05890207031575567 }, { "index": 10, "well": "W11", "x": -6.5, "y": 79.23932066048626, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.754850496946577, "delta": 0.0007292092751693957 }, { "index": 11, "well": "W12", "x": -6.5, "y": 79.4584557107941, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.7548163496208975, "delta": 0.0007633566008484749 }, { "index": 12, "well": "W13", "x": -7.0, "y": 96.94180069960704, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.75486281128817, "delta": 0.0007168949335758512 }, { "index": 13, "well": "W14", "x": -7.0, "y": 93.30060932567785, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.758012179176567, "delta": -0.0024324729548208524 }, { "index": 14, "well": "W15", "x": -7.5, "y": 99.11413191942533, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.752882430348675, "delta": 0.0026972758730705593 }, { "index": 15, "well": "W16", "x": -7.5, "y": 102.09941442430147, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.749679061291659, "delta": 0.005900644930086685 }, { "index": 16, "well": "W17", "x": -8.0, "y": 103.172632971623, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.748450091388418, "delta": 0.007129614833328191 }, { "index": 17, "well": "W18", "x": -8.0, "y": 98.0140698704918, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.7541279773164185, "delta": 0.0014517289053275206 }, { "index": 18, "well": "W19", "x": -8.5, "y": 98.53323676732087, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.753533225571517, "delta": 0.0020464806502289434 }, { "index": 19, "well": "W20", "x": -8.5, "y": 98.2529544302074, "shown": true, "logIC50": -5.753855518889032, "delta": 0.0017241873327140667 } ], "largest": { "index": 8, "well": "W9" } } } ] }