{ "about": { "method": "curve-comparison", "recordedOn": "2026-10-13", "script": "pipeline/assay-analyser/oracles/curve_compare_v2.py", "scriptSha256": "54f37b9571c7915fc098f8d6e71dda4dcb00e809307da101d0773fde0643f6bd", "rScript": "pipeline/assay-analyser/oracles/r/curve_compare_drc.R", "rScriptSha256": "988f9bee7a7ce238d6901aaae6766b135db40927be31a4e2b5a614c59decfc97", "basedOn": { "script": "pipeline/assay-analyser/oracles/curve_compare.py", "sha256": "5bafcb4acca66a7c1de1f0266cfb3c9b10077e4f9396691b158bf6a8433213d6", "predecessor": "curve-compare.json", "changed": "the drc cross-check's agreement rules only (agree): p compared where p > 1e-12, the Wald SE at 1e-2" }, "origin": "Self-constructed curves from known parameters with seeded noise recorded as the responses, and the worked MTT plate (input below); the coverage replicates from a seeded NumPy generator", "input": "pipeline/assay-analyser/fixtures/mtt-example.json", "inputSha256": "50029b58c869ecb47767215f6b6ba9b54ef33575a77dcd1044cf2c6b3c2a8214", "environment": { "image": "ghcr.io/biotechmat/drybench/oracle-env:11b8a5e4456df7eb@sha256:7e69891ca1d9f24838660e0a9887bdb654ce7771d2f2ac7e7275e9b1eb3b6a09", "python": "3.11.15", "scipy": "1.13.1", "numpy": "2.0.2", "recordedOn": "2026-10-13", "r": "R version 4.4.3 (2025-02-28)", "packages": { "drc": "4.0-0", "jsonlite": "2.0.0" }, "cpu": "AMD EPYC 9V45 96-Core Processor", "cpuClass": "x86-64-v3", "simd": [ "SSSE3", "SSE41", "POPCNT", "SSE42", "AVX", "F16C", "FMA3", "AVX2" ], "openblasCore": "Haswell", "threads": 1 }, "crossCheck": { "tool": "R drc", "ran": true, "version": "4.0-0", "r": "R version 4.4.3 (2025-02-28)", "result": "every RSS, F, p and delta within tolerance; the Wald SE within 1e-2 (observed against Gauss-Newton information)", "agrees": true, "worst": { "rss": 3.038450320581769e-15, "F": 6.950807249456473e-15, "p": 2.42881576836229e-07, "delta": 3.5660778797118314e-08, "se": 0.0070693924608108 }, "rows": [ { "case": "same-midpoint", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 2.2500584637827804e-16, "rssShared": 2.184161391141412e-16, "F": 6.950807249456473e-15, "p": 3.6487171098166703e-16, "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 3.5660778797118314e-08, "edcompLog10Ratio": 0.00395683472630024, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.00395683472630024, "lowOfInverse": 0.973482744528454, "highOfInverse": 1.00866334696822 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.00395683472630024, "lowOfInverse": 0.973341972826336, "highOfInverse": 1.00851888772173 }, "se": 0.0029377902196108473 } } }, { "case": "shifted-midpoint", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 7.050823887694817e-16, "rssShared": 2.368252044066514e-15, "F": 4.195449325209679e-16, "p": "both below 1e-12", "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 5.095200648799636e-09, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.0674470918636651, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0674470918636651, "lowOfInverse": 1.14061711731339, "highOfInverse": 1.19635223695625 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0674470918636651, "lowOfInverse": 1.14015352958154, "highOfInverse": 1.19586932568572 }, "se": 0.00071628151416813 } } }, { "case": "shifted-hill-shared", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 0.0, "rssShared": 8.406392552567941e-16, "F": 5.715166021389641e-16, "p": "both below 1e-12", "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 4.5850324392749775e-15, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.068426414937172, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.068426414937172, "lowOfInverse": 1.14779271844539, "highOfInverse": 1.19404020880904 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.068426414937172, "lowOfInverse": 1.14752868642889, "highOfInverse": 1.19376778500053 }, "se": 0.0026524900594135253 } } }, { "case": "shifted-plateaus-shared", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 7.693195628179653e-16, "rssShared": 3.038450320581769e-15, "F": 6.102851867989928e-16, "p": 1.930876019254212e-10, "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 1.2920010510223766e-09, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.0235543130281576, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0235543130281576, "lowOfInverse": 1.04062608188719, "highOfInverse": 1.07111896104784 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0235543130281576, "lowOfInverse": 1.04048916642998, "highOfInverse": 1.07097788433928 }, "se": 0.0023784507611568396 } } }, { "case": "three-curves", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 3.6797035698375244e-16, "rssShared": 1.4767053673385903e-15, "F": 1.246446968518292e-15, "p": "both below 1e-12", "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 4.8217080270294794e-09, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.0283219523544229, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0283219523544229, "lowOfInverse": 1.04510407258467, "highOfInverse": 1.09018527756219 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0283219523544229, "lowOfInverse": 1.04485069439409, "highOfInverse": 1.08992351818478 }, "se": 0.0028270813213184653 }, "C": { "delta": 1.288685299551656e-08, "edcompLog10Ratio": 0.0194125940333445, "fieller": { "row": "A/C:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.0194125940333445, "lowOfInverse": 0.938658994041071, "highOfInverse": 0.97417969800378 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/C:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.0194125940333445, "lowOfInverse": 0.93852653851175, "highOfInverse": 0.974043736069229 }, "se": 0.0009260266740388296 } } }, { "case": "fixed-plateaus", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 2.035219006136817e-16, "rssShared": 1.6004205479099994e-15, "F": 6.867242512117973e-16, "p": 9.83246807704632e-11, "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 5.377742816342371e-15, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.0176947864584812, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0176947864584812, "lowOfInverse": 1.02833729322448, "highOfInverse": 1.0550097230981 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.0176947864584812, "lowOfInverse": 1.02824980989714, "highOfInverse": 1.05492052356881 }, "se": 0.000410494037848219 } } }, { "case": "poorly-determined", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 5.208359008104448e-16, "rssShared": 6.640129160462097e-16, "F": 2.7762240357286547e-15, "p": 1.0349354573304582e-13, "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 1.480727155867778e-09, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.103261502355896, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.103261502355896, "lowOfInverse": 1.18719722635355, "highOfInverse": 1.35810892118117 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.103261502355896, "lowOfInverse": 1.18320689669638, "highOfInverse": 1.3536238807668 } } } }, { "case": "reference-swapped", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 7.050823887694817e-16, "rssShared": 2.368252044066514e-15, "F": 4.195449325209679e-16, "p": "both below 1e-12", "deltas": { "A": { "delta": 5.095200648799636e-09, "edcompLog10Ratio": 0.0674470918636651, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.0674470918636651, "low": 1.14061711731339, "high": 1.19635223695625 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.0674470918636651, "low": 1.14015352958154, "high": 1.19586932568572 }, "se": 0.0007162799913267441 } } }, { "case": "metamorphic-units", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 3.525411943847405e-16, "rssShared": 1.3814803590387989e-15, "F": 1.0488623313024204e-15, "p": "both below 1e-12", "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 3.004458185434809e-13, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.046043372064351, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.046043372064351, "lowOfInverse": 1.09412524637179, "highOfInverse": 1.12995944867203 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.046043372064351, "lowOfInverse": 1.09392837749631, "highOfInverse": 1.12975714071182 }, "se": 0.0007254917636493646 } } }, { "case": "mtt-compounds-a-b", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 4.3004995338779374e-16, "sharedNotCompared": "the shared-midpoint fit runs to its limit; R's shared fit and anova are recorded, not compared", "rRssShared": 3439.70177714807, "rAnova": { "F": 173.533779652774, "p": 0, "columns": [ "ModelDf", "RSS", "Df", "F value", "p value" ], "df": [ 53, 52 ] }, "deltas": { "Compound B": { "delta": 3.499573865521473e-12, "edcompLog10Ratio": 0.0751137378554346, "fieller": { "row": "Compound A/Compound B:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.0751137378554346, "lowOfInverse": 0.825385973858415, "highOfInverse": 0.85736115678525 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "Compound A/Compound B:50/50", "log10Ratio": 0.0751137378554346, "lowOfInverse": 0.825190348810992, "highOfInverse": 0.857159284400821 }, "se": 0.0070693924608108 } } }, { "case": "rising-curves", "converged": true, "rssConstrained": 1.1279823513480243e-16, "rssShared": 2.0045986822729592e-15, "F": 3.3225201006939847e-16, "p": 2.42881576836229e-07, "deltas": { "B": { "delta": 6.650960764843823e-10, "edcompLog10Ratio": -0.029492701010616, "fieller": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.029492701010616, "lowOfInverse": 1.05485673594691, "highOfInverse": 1.08593456913556 }, "deltaMethod": { "row": "A/B:50/50", "log10Ratio": -0.029492701010616, "lowOfInverse": 1.05473092344642, "highOfInverse": 1.08580586704797 }, "se": 0.0002582630384077278 } } } ], "tolerances": { "rss": 1e-06, "F": 1e-05, "p": "1e-4 where p > 1e-12, else both below 1e-12", "delta": 1e-05, "Wald SE": "1e-2 (drc's Hessian against the engine's J'J)" }, "note": "EDcomp's delta-method and Fieller intervals are on the C50 ratio's linear scale and are recorded as information only; the engine's intervals are on log10 C50" }, "tolerances": { "RSS": "1e-6 relative", "F": "1e-5 relative", "p": "1e-4 relative", "delta and its Wald bounds": "1e-6 absolute in log10 units", "profile bounds on delta": "within 1e-3 log10 of the direct profile", "statuses, readings and withholdings": "exact" }, "coverage": { "replicates": 2000, "seed": 20261012, "designs": [ { "design": "duplicates-11x2", "about": "Two curves, eleven half-log concentrations in duplicate, Hill -1, 0 to 100 percent, true delta 0.5, noise SD 5", "replicates": 2000, "errors": 0, "compared": 2000, "ratioWithheldFraction": 0.0, "midpointRejectionRate": 1.0, "midpointWithheldFraction": 0.0, "midpointRejectionWilson95": [ 0.9980829527187469, 0.9999999999999998 ], "profile": { "coverage": 0.954, "wilson95": [ 0.9439163444279334, 0.9623429766406889 ] }, "wald": { "coverage": 0.9525, "wilson95": [ 0.9422790928066445, 0.9609859794038216 ] }, "profileUnresolvedFraction": 0.0 }, { "design": "single-8x1", "about": "Two curves, eight half-log concentrations once each (10^-8.5 to 10^-5 M), Hill -1, true delta 0.5, noise SD 5", "replicates": 2000, "errors": 0, "compared": 2000, "ratioWithheldFraction": 0.3, "midpointRejectionRate": 0.7685, "midpointWithheldFraction": 0.1035, "midpointRejectionWilson95": [ 0.7495103570396379, 0.7864601885703292 ], "profile": { "coverage": 0.9342857142857143, "wilson95": [ 0.9200813694044833, 0.9461133083203849 ] }, "wald": { "coverage": 0.9385714285714286, "wilson95": [ 0.9247535947329497, 0.949989056785256 ] }, "profileUnresolvedFraction": 0.004285714285714286 }, { "design": "null-11x2", "about": "Two curves from one midpoint (true delta 0), duplicates: the midpoint test's rejection rate is its size", "replicates": 2000, "errors": 0, "compared": 2000, "ratioWithheldFraction": 0.0, "midpointRejectionRate": 0.0465, "midpointWithheldFraction": 0.0, "midpointRejectionWilson95": [ 0.03810906851120825, 0.056629693372888146 ], "profile": { "coverage": 0.9535, "wilson95": [ 0.9433703066271119, 0.9618909314887917 ] }, "wald": { "coverage": 0.951, "wilson95": [ 0.9406443633026171, 0.9596264600496927 ] }, "profileUnresolvedFraction": 0.0 } ], "unresolvedSides": "counted as open", "gate": "the two delta designs must cover at least 0.90 by the profile before the copy says approximate 95 percent", "gatePassed": true } }, "oracle": { "engine": "scipy.optimize.least_squares (trf, bounded)", "F": "scipy.stats.f.sf", "threshold": "RSS_min (1 + scipy.stats.f.ppf(0.95, 1, df) / df)", "wald": "scipy.stats.t.ppf(0.975, df), SE from a central-difference Jacobian", "root": "scipy.optimize.brentq, xtol 1e-12", "scipy": "1.13.1", "numpy": "2.0.2", "python": "3.11.15" }, "cases": [ { "name": "same-midpoint", "about": "Two curves from one midpoint (100 nM, Hill -1, 0 to 100 percent), different noise: consistent with one midpoint", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.65776908167399, 103.869769081674, 101.975900990099, 101.90590099009901, 103.40965699682843, 92.11265699682843, 88.40109090909091, 85.6260909090909, 75.54369266479578, 79.96969266479579, 49.912, 51.984, 16.38230733520421, 24.61330733520421, 5.462909090909092, 16.19290909090909, 6.612343003171551, 6.862343003171551, 0.7590990099009901, 3.44109900990099, 2.9472309183260212, -1.0627690816739788 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 101.37374580292395, "bottom": 1.6182947510079133, "logIC50": -7.041074515905391, "hill": -0.9971277828137884 }, "rss": 291.731641391376, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.136663974102561 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.9474246303010805 }, "threshold": 363.26867125073124, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 505.2617056469129, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 505.2617056469129, "df": 36, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.05217453241627, "bottom": -2.3417979231053496, "logIC50": -6.977215001972854, "hill": -0.8789278068444554 }, { "top": 101.37374580315984, "bottom": 1.6182947458292498, "logIC50": -7.041074515990082, "hill": -0.997127781772329 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 520.5056649325941, "df": 37, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.73123466371048, "bottom": -1.7178682904812523, "logIC50": -7.011786994203881, "hill": -0.8767115569629801 }, { "top": 100.79332792721532, "bottom": 1.1395580146772404, "logIC50": -7.011786994203881, "hill": -1.0005957116036224 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 1.0861352209186075, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 0.3042776381973169, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": false }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "consistent with one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 505.2617056469129, "df": 36, "fQuantile": 4.1131652768128895, "threshold": 562.9901751849723, "tQuantile": 2.0280940009804502, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": -0.06385951401722778, "wald": { "low": -0.18858658570153736, "high": 0.060867557667081795, "se": 0.06149965022529145 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -0.1888692448993124 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.06048197702505425 } } } } } } }, { "name": "shifted-midpoint", "about": "B ten-fold less potent than A (100 nM against 1 uM): the data do not support one midpoint; delta near 1", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.94138722023703, 104.15338722023704, 102.86609990009991, 102.79609990009992, 106.15976908167399, 94.86276908167399, 96.50190099009902, 93.72690099009901, 96.50365699682844, 100.92965699682844, 90.82109090909091, 92.8930909090909, 68.33169266479578, 76.56269266479578, 46.372, 57.102000000000004, 27.57230733520421, 27.82230733520421, 8.859909090909092, 11.541909090909092, 5.69734300317155, 1.6873430031715506 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 101.48625108129055, "bottom": -1.8973238035103543, "logIC50": -5.973584536300235, "hill": -0.8651927819513412 }, "rss": 270.18718439120795, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.0962026117012735 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -5.823952746032676 }, "threshold": 336.4411861348129, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 483.7172486467447, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 483.7172486467447, "df": 36, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.05217451368343, "bottom": -2.3417980784699717, "logIC50": -6.977214999475264, "hill": -0.8789278048463571 }, { "top": 101.48625106355013, "bottom": -1.897323584160966, "logIC50": -5.97358453854277, "hill": -0.8651927870589554 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 2304.2176715563755, "df": 37, "estimates": [ { "top": 134.9124463356865, "bottom": -81.93415668237535, "logIC50": -6.0484013348381325, "hill": -0.24070461897101747 }, { "top": 101.71655341296425, "bottom": 1.6222080726467243, "logIC50": -6.0484013348381325, "hill": -0.913635249519428 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 135.48827420997895, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 9.25074319174021e-14, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 483.7172486467446, "df": 36, "fQuantile": 4.1131652768128895, "threshold": 538.9841650614462, "tQuantile": 2.0280940009804502, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": 1.0036304608577404, "wald": { "low": 0.8539760865201039, "high": 1.153284835195377, "se": 0.07379064987386605 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.8588432780497763 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 1.162823771157039 } } } } } } }, { "name": "shifted-hill-shared", "about": "The shifted pair with Hill named as a shared constraint; its own nested test against the separate fit", "scale": "percent", "shared": [ "hill" ], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.97174109043695, 104.18374109043695, 102.95969082463724, 102.88969082463724, 106.44338722023703, 95.14638722023703, 97.33376147191983, 94.55876147191982, 98.78093161496699, 103.20693161496699, 96.08334961177454, 98.15534961177453, 75.7232469183438, 83.9542469183438, 46.372, 57.102000000000004, 20.180753081656192, 20.430753081656192, 3.5976503882254742, 6.279650388225474, 3.420068385033029, -0.5899316149669708 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 101.11292377543744, "bottom": -0.6420166379526243, "logIC50": -5.987529247874253, "hill": -1.203764934142866 }, "rss": 262.7190965869174, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.06986634441563 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -5.8993082156708345 }, "threshold": 327.1418097610007, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 476.2491608424542, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 560.551453136853, "df": 37, "estimates": [ { "top": 100.14308088583833, "bottom": -0.4286185049852584, "logIC50": -6.976566205200572, "hill": -1.02372195049774 }, { "top": 102.03565603694175, "bottom": -4.075832602955565, "logIC50": -5.959575210004255, "hill": -1.02372195049774 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 4327.6337434187535, "df": 38, "estimates": [ { "top": 94.243888042093, "bottom": -16.68948065504118, "logIC50": -6.417677670707384, "hill": -0.743803341508712 }, { "top": 110.14170597936956, "bottom": 6.1105884323047555, "logIC50": -6.417677670707384, "hill": -0.743803341508712 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 248.65165179832584, "df1": 1, "df2": 37, "p": 5.273969888608717e-18, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": { "hill": { "rss": 560.551453136853, "df": 37, "test": { "F": 6.372467968720075, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 0.01614084866475618, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "withheld": null } }, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 560.551453136853, "df": 37, "fQuantile": 4.105455897235966, "threshold": 622.7492712175255, "tQuantile": 2.0261924630291093, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": 1.0169909951963172, "wald": { "low": 0.8909543356505629, "high": 1.1430276547420715, "se": 0.06220369577198629 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.8923779638442827 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 1.1460879454051585 } } } } } } }, { "name": "shifted-plateaus-shared", "about": "The shifted pair with Top and Bottom named as shared constraints, each its own nested test", "scale": "percent", "shared": [ "top", "bottom" ], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 95.85606714644396, 100.06806714644397, 98.59722843741883, 98.52722843741884, 101.31875562133685, 90.02175562133685, 89.93135513895032, 87.15635513895032, 85.17013341063513, 89.59613341063513, 69.43050584757549, 71.50250584757548, 36.52701806010679, 44.75801806010679, 18.042680828918474, 28.772680828918475, 13.390642718934345, 13.640642718934345, 5.047813182181249, 7.72981318218125, 6.364903598080717, 2.3549035980807167 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 97.43750956768156, "bottom": 4.601928890655836, "logIC50": -6.644539337006826, "hill": -0.9621071284837598 }, "rss": 286.79528455425765, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.749075021289282 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.534630391769628 }, "threshold": 357.12184473411855, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 500.3253488097945, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 591.1033241124865, "df": 38, "estimates": [ { "top": 99.89871991714291, "bottom": 0.05642102608922922, "logIC50": -6.980095405266176, "hill": -0.9704746608186648 }, { "top": 99.89871991714291, "bottom": 0.05642102608922922, "logIC50": -6.611607226561132, "hill": -0.8050488400485696 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 1496.6423765631755, "df": 39, "estimates": [ { "top": 100.46255910847161, "bottom": 0.7453454587853646, "logIC50": -6.831105082521999, "hill": -0.9569635647499318 }, { "top": 100.46255910847161, "bottom": 0.7453454587853646, "logIC50": -6.831105082521999, "hill": -0.7805378533089616 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 58.21399168206656, "df1": 1, "df2": 38, "p": 3.514196821750932e-09, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": { "top": { "rss": 547.2747420479552, "df": 37, "test": { "F": 3.3781581536783785, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 0.07432929593960629, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": false }, "withheld": null }, "bottom": { "rss": 571.6154964840727, "df": 37, "test": { "F": 5.129552844722411, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 0.029639322928826945, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "withheld": null } }, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 591.1033241124862, "df": 38, "fQuantile": 4.098171730880841, "threshold": 654.8518223468939, "tQuantile": 2.024394163911969, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": 0.3684881770619491, "wald": { "low": 0.2707508577685715, "high": 0.4662254963553267, "se": 0.04827978712629193 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.27104408304879807 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.46614087316057606 } } } } } } }, { "name": "three-curves", "about": "Three curves against reference A: delta for B (0.5) and C (-0.3)", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.87309990009992, 104.08509990009992, 102.65076908167399, 102.58076908167399, 105.484900990099, 94.18790099009901, 94.42665699682844, 91.65165699682844, 90.47809090909091, 94.90409090909091, 75.88669266479579, 77.95869266479578, 42.357, 50.588, 20.39730733520421, 31.12730733520421, 12.637909090909092, 12.887909090909092, 2.8343430031715506, 5.516343003171551, 3.62209900990099, -0.3879009900990098 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "C", "label": "C", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 106.67999876585661, 87.0599987658566, 101.87576961274205, 98.32276961274205, 99.33790568972323, 95.60790568972324, 90.6752469183438, 83.4932469183438, 59.248682015314316, 63.635682015314316, 35.1140575416878, 31.959057541687798, 12.691688860321005, 16.558688860321006, 7.589672103420393, 2.796672103420393, 0.08916622418296072, -5.6668337758170395, 7.215687873668797, -0.39831212633120283, 5.507238528080173, 1.828238528080172 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 101.51707589158177, "bottom": 1.3104236094229067, "logIC50": -6.536724083689325, "hill": -0.9448613581623022 }, "rss": 284.6025957057057, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.636614704106463 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.4304247124755785 }, "threshold": 354.39147527305914, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "C", "estimates": { "top": 100.14169614118616, "bottom": 1.4836880946020257, "logIC50": -7.296165896080118, "hill": -1.104955127749901 }, "rss": 428.736873662379, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.403509850227839 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.189075010331862 }, "threshold": 533.8696675777493, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 926.8695336236214, "df": 54 }, "constrained": { "rss": 926.8695336236214, "df": 54, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.05217451642741, "bottom": -2.3417980168283186, "logIC50": -6.977215000572988, "hill": -0.8789278063978372 }, { "top": 101.51707590700981, "bottom": 1.3104234342228445, "logIC50": -6.536724082282943, "hill": -0.9448613531093317 }, { "top": 100.14169616304129, "bottom": 1.4836879653501176, "logIC50": -7.296165894932032, "hill": -1.104955123371263 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 3079.4724590595747, "df": 56, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.14464588531041, "bottom": -2.2489457756134286, "logIC50": -6.982132770498396, "hill": -0.8788684628018406 }, { "top": 110.75182310545601, "bottom": 8.20614141104708, "logIC50": -6.982132770498396, "hill": -0.7557978786359172 }, { "top": 94.8982142057617, "bottom": -4.521384678718351, "logIC50": -6.982132770498396, "hill": -0.9736113735265125 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 62.70599785446388, "df1": 2, "df2": 54, "p": 8.329935377804523e-15, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 926.8695336236214, "df": 54, "fQuantile": 4.019540960205442, "threshold": 995.8619420526336, "tQuantile": 2.004879288188057, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": 0.4404909182900454, "wald": { "low": 0.29853563430052554, "high": 0.5824462022795652, "se": 0.07080490323076473 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.2991665152102967 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.5850423505318856 } } }, "C": { "estimate": -0.3189508943590438, "wald": { "low": -0.4510851075118699, "high": -0.18681668120621764, "se": 0.06590631861544374 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -0.4512878321537076 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -0.1865981665638576 } } } } } } }, { "name": "fixed-plateaus", "about": "Top 100 and Bottom 0 fixed on both curves (percent of control): two free parameters per curve", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0 } }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.81476147191982, 104.02676147191983, 102.46731212633121, 102.39731212633122, 104.91483377581703, 93.61783377581703, 92.71932789657961, 89.94432789657961, 85.88831113967899, 90.31431113967899, 66.5259424583122, 68.59794245831219, 31.043317984685693, 39.274317984685695, 13.005753081656184, 23.735753081656185, 9.482094310276757, 9.732094310276757, 1.7252303872579509, 4.407230387257951, 3.259001234143384, -0.7509987658566161 ], "fixed": { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0 } } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0, "logIC50": -6.980721450814751, "hill": -0.9671483251748058 }, "rss": 243.3730238275357, "df": 20, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.040606299929892 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.920907053439475 }, "threshold": 296.32178826829414, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0, "logIC50": -6.702016958162319, "hill": -0.9707356444803145 }, "rss": 315.22453927901404, "df": 20, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.769576981466097 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.6340993898541525 }, "threshold": 383.80547571040296, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 558.5975631065498, "df": 40 }, "constrained": { "rss": 558.5975631065498, "df": 40, "estimates": [ { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0, "logIC50": -6.980721450814751, "hill": -0.9671483251748058 }, { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0, "logIC50": -6.702016958162319, "hill": -0.9707356444803145 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 1136.569638474892, "df": 41, "estimates": [ { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0, "logIC50": -6.840025672914889, "hill": -0.9533550045999916 }, { "top": 100.0, "bottom": 0.0, "logIC50": -6.840025672914889, "hill": -0.9624897411114623 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 41.387368190727074, "df1": 1, "df2": 40, "p": 1.1630574904308872e-07, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 558.5975631065498, "df": 40, "fQuantile": 4.084745733301651, "threshold": 615.6407884198544, "tQuantile": 2.0210753903062733, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": 0.278704492652432, "wald": { "low": 0.19112274347579336, "high": 0.36628624182907066, "se": 0.043334231665334635 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.19122258765305103 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.36637312257458515 } } } } } } }, { "name": "poorly-determined", "about": "B's midpoint near the top of the tested range with a shallow slope and noisy plateau: its own interval is wider than two log10 units, so the ratio is withheld; the F test is still reported", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 106.86797943275005, 90.11797943275005, 84.09152138840007, 70.57652138840007, 96.12246125969271, 112.13046125969271, 99.64392244440491, 104.4309224444049, 108.87041089712179, 89.81741089712179, 123.84259575961597, 88.55059575961597, 98.5268550672625, 122.1868550672625, 88.97568291216677, 91.26168291216678, 76.93052072864229, 85.39452072864229, 48.345877042959984, 63.144877042959976, 70.38939447268314, 55.56139447268313 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 98.97908354997304, "bottom": 58.65581564341862, "logIC50": -5.500733480083468, "hill": -2.3921937783354346 }, "rss": 3278.9123743617442, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.098009505332882 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -3.857550294335486 }, "threshold": 4082.9514950831194, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": true } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 3492.442438617278, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 3492.442438617278, "df": 36, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.05217451639686, "bottom": -2.341798147536045, "logIC50": -6.977214998360427, "hill": -0.8789278036208203 }, { "top": 98.97908365218755, "bottom": 58.65581543958491, "logIC50": -5.500733480167607, "hill": -2.3921934222290284 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 5478.777173121343, "df": 37, "estimates": [ { "top": 175.40550105573593, "bottom": -151.51306540068867, "logIC50": -5.527114371509852, "hill": -0.15127089357104123 }, { "top": 99.14174260840285, "bottom": 58.964998525432264, "logIC50": -5.527114371509852, "hill": -2.261930746990027 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 20.475083469223243, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 6.351097185951953e-05, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": "poorly-determined" } } }, { "name": "own-fit-at-box", "about": "B's own fit runs to its box (a shallow curve whose midpoint the data do not reach): no comparison is made", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 93.93831631234163, 106.19331631234164, 110.16543684266698, 110.08043684266697, 117.72299160004309, 95.69299160004309, 104.53823162617604, 95.43423162617603, 83.96482046277382, 91.17382046277382, 97.85842651680137, 87.34442651680138, 91.32999710034238, 104.44799710034239, 93.07604209450814, 93.09404209450814, 81.06645753418307, 75.86245753418308, 44.7973335052317, 73.38933350523169, 31.484605527316866, 48.71260552731687 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 103.49827610012164, "bottom": -1693.283115927206, "logIC50": -1.004143628360801, "hill": -0.40905327528765006 }, "rss": 1739.2971124015912, "df": 18, "atBox": true, "profile": null } ], "status": "refused", "reason": "own-fit-at-box" } }, { "name": "reference-swapped", "about": "The shifted pair with B as the reference: delta negated, the F test unchanged", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "B", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 99.94138722023703, 104.15338722023704, 102.86609990009991, 102.79609990009992, 106.15976908167399, 94.86276908167399, 96.50190099009902, 93.72690099009901, 96.50365699682844, 100.92965699682844, 90.82109090909091, 92.8930909090909, 68.33169266479578, 76.56269266479578, 46.372, 57.102000000000004, 27.57230733520421, 27.82230733520421, 8.859909090909092, 11.541909090909092, 5.69734300317155, 1.6873430031715506 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217453317756, "bottom": -2.341797919469941, "logIC50": -6.977215002004882, "hill": -0.8789278066471243 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.889933146206401 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 101.48625108129055, "bottom": -1.8973238035103543, "logIC50": -5.973584536300235, "hill": -0.8651927819513412 }, "rss": 270.18718439120795, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.0962026117012735 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -5.823952746032676 }, "threshold": 336.4411861348129, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 483.7172486467447, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 483.7172486467447, "df": 36, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.05217451368343, "bottom": -2.3417980784699717, "logIC50": -6.977214999475264, "hill": -0.8789278048463571 }, { "top": 101.48625106355013, "bottom": -1.897323584160966, "logIC50": -5.97358453854277, "hill": -0.8651927870589554 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 2304.2176715563755, "df": 37, "estimates": [ { "top": 134.9124463356865, "bottom": -81.93415668237535, "logIC50": -6.0484013348381325, "hill": -0.24070461897101747 }, { "top": 101.71655341296425, "bottom": 1.6222080726467243, "logIC50": -6.0484013348381325, "hill": -0.913635249519428 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 135.48827420997895, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 9.25074319174021e-14, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "B", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 483.7172486467446, "df": 36, "fQuantile": 4.1131652768128895, "threshold": 538.9841650614462, "tQuantile": 2.0280940009804502, "deltas": { "A": { "estimate": -1.0036304609140179, "wald": { "low": -1.1532848354793912, "high": -0.8539760863486445, "se": 0.07379064998615707 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -1.162823771157039 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -0.8588432780497762 } } } } } } }, { "name": "metamorphic-units", "about": "The shifted pair with every concentration x 1e-3 (log10 shifted by -3): delta, F and the RSS unchanged", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -12.5, -12.5, -12.0, -12.0, -11.5, -11.5, -11.0, -11.0, -10.5, -10.5, -10.0, -10.0, -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5 ], "y": [ 99.82176908167399, 105.123769081674, 103.90890099009901, 96.96890099009902, 95.74265699682844, 94.82465699682844, 93.1880909090909, 90.6850909090909, 78.96269266479578, 68.58569266479579, 56.266, 49.614, 26.747307335204212, 23.47930733520421, 7.574909090909092, 10.942909090909092, 6.3633430031715505, 2.2553430031715505, 0.3790990099009901, 3.73309900990099, -3.1657690816739787, -5.742769081673979 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -12.5, -12.5, -12.0, -12.0, -11.5, -11.5, -11.0, -11.0, -10.5, -10.5, -10.0, -10.0, -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5 ], "y": [ 99.94138722023703, 104.15338722023704, 102.86609990009991, 102.79609990009992, 106.15976908167399, 94.86276908167399, 96.50190099009902, 93.72690099009901, 96.50365699682844, 100.92965699682844, 90.82109090909091, 92.8930909090909, 68.33169266479578, 76.56269266479578, 46.372, 57.102000000000004, 27.57230733520421, 27.82230733520421, 8.859909090909092, 11.541909090909092, 5.69734300317155, 1.6873430031715506 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 102.05217434897911, "bottom": -2.34179776194428, "logIC50": -9.977215001250702, "hill": -0.8789278155820747 }, "rss": 213.53006425553676, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -10.064580730685492 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -9.889933146206403 }, "threshold": 265.890879522831, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 101.48625105485192, "bottom": -1.8973229954270827, "logIC50": -8.973584546515086, "hill": -0.8651927918995496 }, "rss": 270.18718439120835, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -9.096202611701274 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -8.823952746032676 }, "threshold": 336.4411861348134, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 483.7172486467452, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 483.7172486467452, "df": 36, "estimates": [ { "top": 102.0521743489798, "bottom": -2.3417977619777735, "logIC50": -9.977215001250903, "hill": -0.8789278155780448 }, { "top": 101.4862510548489, "bottom": -1.8973229954370936, "logIC50": -8.973584546515339, "hill": -0.8651927919136516 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 2304.217671556377, "df": 37, "estimates": [ { "top": 134.91244862800013, "bottom": -81.93415778956225, "logIC50": -9.048401360245057, "hill": -0.24070461346182337 }, { "top": 101.7165532915936, "bottom": 1.622209851358051, "logIC50": -9.048401360245057, "hill": -0.9136352799581305 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 135.48827420997887, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 9.250743191740299e-14, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 483.7172486467452, "df": 36, "fQuantile": 4.1131652768128895, "threshold": 538.9841650614468, "tQuantile": 2.0280940009804502, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": 1.0036304547355641, "wald": { "low": 0.8539760817190862, "high": 1.153284827752042, "se": 0.0737906492224373 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.8588432780497781 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 1.1628237711570413 } } } } } } }, { "name": "mtt-compounds-a-b", "about": "The worked MTT plate (pipeline/assay-analyser/fixtures/mtt-example.json), Compounds A and B as percent of the plate's controls: forcing one midpoint drives B's fit to the edge of its search, so the midpoint F test is withheld; the difference of log C50s from the constrained fit is given (CSO ruling of 12 October 2026)", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "Compound A", "curves": [ { "id": "Compound A", "label": "Compound A", "x": [ -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962 ], "y": [ 4.14595452141724, 5.33051295610788, 12.860920148069804, 35.5367530407192, 74.6271813855103, 81.73453199365414, 105.93336858804865, 86.47276573241672, 107.7102062400846, 100.2644103648863, 3.2998413537810687, 6.345848757271286, 12.522474881015334, 33.0830248545743, 68.87361184558435, 83.76520359598096, 99.84135378106822, 97.2184029613961, 95.10312004230565, 96.96456901110523, 3.2998413537810687, 8.122686409307244, 13.453199365415124, 32.575356953992596, 65.40454785827605, 86.81121099947119, 88.9264939185616, 102.2104706504495, 97.2184029613961, 96.96456901110523 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "Compound B", "label": "Compound B", "x": [ -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962, -4.0, -4.477121254719663, -4.954242509439325, -5.431363764158987, -5.9084850188786495, -6.385606273598312, -6.862727528317975, -7.339848783037637, -7.8169700377573, -8.294091292476962 ], "y": [ 16.414595452141725, 18.02221047065045, 15.314648334214699, 19.71443680592279, 22.083553675304074, 39.09042834479112, 62.527763088313066, 73.44262295081968, 98.3183500793231, 89.09571655208885, 15.314648334214699, 16.076150185087254, 18.191433104177687, 21.660497091485986, 28.514013749338975, 42.89793759915388, 62.189317821258605, 80.88841882601797, 89.8572184029614, 94.17239555790587, 12.437863564251717, 17.091485986250664, 18.02221047065045, 17.176097303014277, 26.906398730830247, 43.15177154944474, 61.427815970386035, 79.78847170809094, 94.51084082496034, 93.49550502379694 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "Compound A", "estimates": { "top": 98.23627953208944, "bottom": 3.0369018010253126, "logIC50": -5.665647204192236, "hill": -1.2823903912343009 }, "rss": 565.5376752025097, "df": 26, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -5.742723710965986 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -5.58672565330437 }, "threshold": 657.4419254050944, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "Compound B", "estimates": { "top": 96.78878389902883, "bottom": 15.538387446334902, "logIC50": -6.73539803183427, "hill": -0.9791144934350114 }, "rss": 227.5341772138992, "df": 26, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.819066123562383 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.657062684801799 }, "threshold": 264.5102424155985, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 793.0718524164093, "df": 52 }, "constrained": { "rss": 793.0718524164093, "df": 52, "estimates": [ { "top": 98.23627953208944, "bottom": 3.0369018010253126, "logIC50": -5.665647204192236, "hill": -1.2823903912343009 }, { "top": 96.78878389902883, "bottom": 15.538387446334902, "logIC50": -6.73539803183427, "hill": -0.9791144934350114 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 3439.7017771504525, "df": 53, "estimates": [ { "top": 98.23689176175024, "bottom": 3.038450266557635, "logIC50": -5.665696924495042, "hill": -1.2824139375269699 }, { "top": 2156.814532594295, "bottom": -2084.907456371429, "logIC50": -5.665696924495042, "hill": -0.008770641902506753 } ] }, "midpointTest": null, "midpointWithheld": { "parameter": "bottom", "curve": "Compound B" }, "reading": null, "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "Compound A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 793.0718524164091, "df": 52, "fQuantile": 4.026631400264279, "threshold": 854.4835451780567, "tQuantile": 2.006646805061688, "deltas": { "Compound B": { "estimate": -1.0697508246875262, "wald": { "low": -1.1919603345839782, "high": -0.9475413147910743, "se": 0.06090235191772828 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -1.1955617228081303 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -0.9508493835930371 } } } } } } }, { "name": "rising-curves", "about": "Two rising (activation) curves, Hill +1.2, B 0.4 log10 to the right: delta near 0.4", "scale": "percent", "shared": [], "reference": "A", "curves": [ { "id": "A", "label": "A", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 0.23690009990009991, 5.5389000999001, 5.29552856191522, -1.6444714380847798, 0.36816622418296086, -0.5498337758170391, 8.21409431027676, 5.71109431027676, 23.064000891310172, 12.687000891310174, 56.266, 49.614, 82.64599910868982, 79.37799910868982, 92.54890568972323, 95.91690568972324, 101.73783377581704, 97.62983377581703, 98.99247143808476, 102.34647143808476, 96.41909990009992, 93.84209990009992 ], "fixed": {} }, { "id": "B", "label": "B", "x": [ -9.5, -9.5, -9.0, -9.0, -8.5, -8.5, -8.0, -8.0, -7.5, -7.5, -7.0, -7.0, -6.5, -6.5, -6.0, -6.0, -5.5, -5.5, -5.0, -5.0, -4.5, -4.5 ], "y": [ 0.00610215099587633, 4.218102150995876, 3.0976521225579337, 3.0276521225579334, 6.9970676104824125, -4.299932389517587, -0.4614621061780464, -3.2364621061780467, 7.2479319697100175, 11.673931969710019, 24.78792064662891, 26.859920646628908, 49.221139188366735, 57.452139188366736, 80.36706946347533, 91.09706946347534, 98.97932189603375, 99.22932189603375, 98.58101824748285, 101.26301824748283, 102.33091409286305, 98.32091409286305 ], "fixed": {} } ], "expected": { "own": [ { "id": "A", "estimates": { "top": 98.51015265122412, "bottom": 1.318771026392166, "logIC50": -7.020944436439786, "hill": 1.3493157450293345 }, "rss": 218.78197965757843, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -7.085900099214462 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.955613541847658 }, "threshold": 272.4306443578063, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } }, { "id": "B", "estimates": { "top": 101.93003709715857, "bottom": 1.1557319387250582, "logIC50": -6.559984829443767, "hill": 1.2193166759282181 }, "rss": 285.15692322397655, "df": 18, "atBox": false, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.639012329349128 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": -6.480835862591646 }, "threshold": 355.0817323190194, "unbounded": false, "poorlyDetermined": false } } ], "status": "compared", "separate": { "rss": 503.93890288155507, "df": 36 }, "constrained": { "rss": 503.93890288155507, "df": 36, "estimates": [ { "top": 98.5101526483117, "bottom": 1.318771019143739, "logIC50": -7.020944436406891, "hill": 1.3493157456014802 }, { "top": 101.93003709648916, "bottom": 1.1557319628657816, "logIC50": -6.559984829287617, "hill": 1.2193166770014687 } ] }, "shared": { "rss": 1701.3904886843934, "df": 37, "estimates": [ { "top": 103.36882813966413, "bottom": 4.450800466725349, "logIC50": -6.7982123556510405, "hill": 1.185546732529982 }, { "top": 97.02870592213982, "bottom": -2.739867723788202, "logIC50": -6.7982123556510405, "hill": 1.1446620097915179 } ] }, "midpointTest": { "F": 85.54262598582167, "df1": 1, "df2": 36, "p": 4.7938664690615474e-11, "alpha": 0.05, "preferFull": true }, "midpointWithheld": null, "reading": "the data do not support one midpoint", "constraintTests": {}, "ratio": { "reference": "A", "withheld": null, "rssMin": 503.9389028815549, "df": 36, "fQuantile": 4.1131652768128895, "threshold": 561.5162361306548, "tQuantile": 2.0280940009804502, "deltas": { "B": { "estimate": 0.4609596073384449, "wald": { "low": 0.3627782768663933, "high": 0.5591409378104965, "se": 0.04841064093902321 }, "profile": { "low": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.362534726103089 }, "high": { "status": "crossing", "value": 0.5592326151605034 } } } } } } } ] }